“My eyesight isn’t great,” Ma recalled with a weary chuckle. “I glanced at it briefly and thought, ‘Huh? Who’s suing me?’” He paused, his smile fading. “At the time, I thought it might be a joke.”
Ma, a Hui Muslim originally from China, had arrived in the United States just four years earlier and had been waiting on his asylum claim ever since. But by 2023 he had become a well-known activist and vocal critic of the government in China. Christmas was not a traditional holiday in his faith, but the family had adopted it in exile. “As long as it’s a happy holiday, we’ll celebrate it,” Ma liked to say.